It’s strange to think that Beyond Good & Evil was a failure on release. It was critically well-received but sales were poor, and it took years to gain a cult following. Now, it’s revered as a masterpiece, gathering a devoted fan base that still pines for the sequel that’s all but passed into legend.
Developed by Ubisoft Montpellier, BG&E is the brainchild of Michel Ancel, a highly influential designer. He's responsible for Rayman and hugely underrated adaptation of Peter Jackson's King Kong. He also created the Rabbids, but nobody's perfect.
BG&E is a game that tries to do a lot of things and succeeds at most of them. A bright, pastel-coloured adventure, it's easily accessible for all ages, but presents dark and complex themes to anyone that looks for them. This pristine remaster, Beyond Good & Evil 20th Anniversary Edition, arrives to remind fans of the original's charm, and hopefully garner a new generation of followers.
The story puts you in the functional sneakers of shutterbug activist Jade. She juggles running an orphanage with her uncle Pey'j (who happens to be a grumpy old pig man), and a freelance photojournalism job. Kicking things off with a bang, the peaceful child refuge comes under attack from a creepy insectoid race called the Domz. After taking a research gig to help pay for repairs, she’s hired by the rebellion group IRIS. The rebels are trying to uncover a conspiracy surrounding the Domz and planetary peacekeepers, the Alpha Section. Jade takes on infiltration missions for IRIS, gathering intel with support from her porcine uncle and kindhearted ex-soldier Double H.
It’s tough to assign BG&E a genre. It’s part adventure, with a semi-open world to explore. Wildlife photography is the backbone of the game's economy, so almost every new area will have you pull out your camera and try to get a good shot of something that may or may not want to eat you. There’s combat and boss encounters, with Jade employing a fighting style that feels like a precursor to the Arkham games. A large chunk of the main IRIS mission involves rudimentary stealth and mild puzzling. Then there’s hovercraft traversal, complete with high-speed water races and vehicle combat sections.
All those systems might suggest an overstuffed endeavour, choking on its aspirations. However, Ancel’s opus never feels bloated or messy. At its heart, it’s a simple adventure game. The exploration and progression are linked to the collecting of pearls, which can be traded to upgrade Jade’s hovercraft and open up more areas of the map. You can acquire pearls from currency exchange, exploration, side activities, and your photos. Navigating the plot is linear, but the game gently nudges you into diversions, which always feel rewarding once discovered.
Beyond Good & Evil remains an audio-visual treat even to this day. The vibrant art style of the Rayman series translates well to this cartoony science fiction fable. The designers at Montpellier present the planet Hyllis as a cultural melting pot, with species of all kinds scraping a living in the floating population centres. Flying cars zip by as you explore the city canals. Propaganda plasters the walls of every home, while protesters decry the despotic rule of the Alpha Section. The areas Jade infiltrates are creepy industrial sprawls, filled with pollution and deadly creatures.
Created during a time of great political turmoil, the game takes its title from the moral and ethical writings of Nietzsche. It’s an experience that tries to squeeze in some challenging ideological subtext amid the air-hockey minigames and Jamaican rhinos.
But how does it hold up today? The 20th (technically it’s the 21st) anniversary edition comes with a fresh lick of paint, revamped audio, and a collection of extras. For those of us who remember the original PlayStation 2 release, the controls are tweaked just enough to be meaningful. Interact has now been moved to its own button and dodge feels more comfortable in parallel to attack.
The visual update is largely great, with resolution and performance modes offering 4K at 60 frames-per-second with noticeably improved textures. There's the odd bit of inconsistency; humans still have a cloudy complexion, while animals like Pey'j have eerily detailed skin texture. Hovercraft sections look good, but races have a tendency to chug, not quite coping with the speed and screen clutter.
The fantastic score by Christophe Heral has been re-recorded, so there are crisp new versions of earworms like ‘Akuda House Propaganda’ and ‘Mamago’s Garage’. Expect to hear them in your head for months to come.
Supplemental galleries offer gorgeous concept art, cut level footage, and insight into the game's creation. It’s a lovingly curated set of materials, which also includes tantalising morsels indicating Beyond Good & Evil 2 might still be alive. This sequel teasing extends to new collectibles scattered across the main game, containing extra lore linking to events outside of this story. It's clear that this return to Hyllis is meant to drum up excitement for what's to come.
Capping off the goodies in this edition are extra outfits for Jade, Peyj, and Double H, as well as a speedrun mode that should extend its lifespan beyond the main story.
If there’s any criticism to be levelled at this fascinating and still enjoyable game, it’s that it feels like it was made in 2003. Movement is floaty, the camera struggles to cope in cramped interiors, and stealth sometimes feels like trial and error. Combat straddles the line between graceful and clunky; the Dai-jo staff and Gyro-disc launcher are imprecise tools that lack a sense of impact.
Yet despite creaking in its old age, this is definitely an experience worth having in 2024. Jade is still a great protagonist, and the world of Hyllis is a unique environment to explore. This is an adventure game that focuses on investigation over combat. Design, music, and good writing work together to create an atmospheric experience with a real sense of place. Its influences are obvious and its imitators numerous, but there’s still nothing quite like Beyond Good & Evil. Now, pretty please Ubisoft, can we have that sequel now?
Conclusion
A bona fide classic remastered with love and care. This edition brings smooth visuals, a beautifully recreated musical score, and well-presented supplemental materials. It certainly shows its age, but like all great art, Beyond Good & Evil weathers the test of time with grace.
Comments 64
Finally a good freaking Ubisoft game again. Though wasn't this being remade or was that one a completely new reboot
I bought this as soon as I saw it £18 is a decent price.
They don't make them like this anymore. It's just what I've been wanting for ages.
I'll finally finish it this time, didn't on GameCube and barely played it on PS3 but now in a bit of a lull period for me it's come out at the right time
I never played the original so it looks like this is a good time to finally dive in.
Yeah, think i may grab this tonight. Ive always hear it was good but for reasons or another never played it.
Is there a platinum trophy ?
@Specky Did you not play the latest Prince of Persia? Avatar? Both great games.
Yeah i might have to pick this up as its been ages since i last played it.
Another year another load of remasters etc.
todays remaster headlines.
Mickey and his paint brush
Luigi mansion 2, boo
Beyond this and that.
At least the second half of the year looks new.
@LazyLombax There is
I think if you took all the resources of all these remasters etc over 2023 and 2024.
You could make the most amazing new ip that would blow every AAA game out of the water.
I first played this on the Xbox 360 and loved it. Good reason to play it again on PS5.
Coolio, I was out of the loop when this originally released but have been intrigued by it since… um… re-entering the loop I guess 🤷♂️
@Specky I don't get this whole "Ubisoft makes bad games" schtick. Their games, while rarely groundbreaking, are always good quality. I can't remember the last truly bad game they made.
Any idea if the vertical controls can be inverted? I seem to remember buying a version of this on PS3 or PS4 and it wasn't possible to invert vertical so I had to stop playing.
How does it compare to ps3 version. I have it but haven't played it. I know with sly game and jak games, the hd collections were supposedly superior to the ps4 emulated ps2 games
As much as I enjoyed this first time around I'm reticent to play it again, even with a lick of paint. Worried it'll muddy the fond memories I have.
@TrevorO I'd like to know about inverting controls too - I also bought the PS3 version and the inability to invert meant I had to stop playing as well.
@TheFakulty it’s sharper, the colours pop more. Performance mode is very smooth. It can’t be understated how crisp the soundtrack remaster is, though.
@adge_uk all controls can be inverted. Individual modes, like 3rd person cam and photo mode, can be tweaked separately as well.
N.i.c.e. i had the ps3 version.but the ps4 version looks good enough.word up son
@Bentleyma
They're not. They're mediocre at best at everything they do and even worse in writing. Their manipulative and make the experience very grinding, for the player to spend way more time in their shallow empty games. Talking mostly about AC here.
You can look at older AC and Far Cry games to see what's missing. Look at how immersive, smooth, interactive with the world/ npc's they were. It's all missing and that's frustrating.
I want the best out of them and what's even more frustrating is that fanboys keep defending and supporting their nonsense blindly.
@DennisReynolds
I haven't and I never will, because they're definitely not great lol
https://youtu.be/rA4JhyP7kgM
I just picked it up. I’m looking forward to starting it later today. I never got around to playing it when it first released even though I owned it.
@Specky Prince of Persia The Lost Crown is a great game, and is universally praised.
@OldGamer999 the resources to spruce up an old game, are nothing compared to making a whole brand new AAA game, that's why so many publishers are doing it. It's also a surefire seller because it's a game proven to sell well, not a brand new ip that comes with risks.
@BecauseBecause beyond good and evil was a notorious financial flop so it's definitely not proven to sell well
I will play this one, always wanted to!! The price is very good, so soon I will get it!!
I remember in GAME seeing loads of copies on release and obviously nobody buying. I got one though and thoroughly enjoyed this fun, quirky adventure.
@kendomustdie excellent! Just downloaded it!
@TrevorO @adge_uk You can invert controls
@BecauseBecause
I know but it’s bloody boring when you have played them already on the older console.
I never played this when it originally came out, so it'll be interesting to finally play this at some point. I just have to wait and see how much the physical editions of this will be when pre-orders start next month. It's not like I'd be able to play this right away anyways.
Played it on deck. So far so good. But not quite wow to me as many said.(Camera part is my favourite)Maybe i got distracted with amazing sand land game
I bought BG&E the day it came out on PS2 in 2003 (when you actually HAD to preorder to guarantee your copy) and I happily dropped $20 on it again today. It’s one of my absolute favorites! Enjoy, everyone!
@DennisReynolds lol erm.. no they weren't.. especially Avatar. .so boring! Full of ubi clutter..the story is super ass too..aswell the performance, it's buggy as hell.. you an ubi employee!?
@rusty82 they didn't say it did, in the first paragraph they said it didn't.. lol
@Bentleyma Avatar is a buggy mess, and they're getting worse every big release..lol
This game has a very special part in my heart, I can still hear their voices in my head perfectly, I bought it when it was xbox, still one the best games I've played..truly special..
Jiggle physics? Or pass?
I can actually hear Secundo in that subheading.
@DarianStarfrog I played through Avatar and can't remember encountering any bugs.
@DarianStarfrog No but i can put together a coherent sentence unlike you.
@Specky You haven't played them and then say they aren't great, yeah pick a lane you can't say both.
@LazyLombax
Yes. Fortunately the speedrun trophy has no clear time requirements (unless the whole mode has a time limit). I hate speedrun trophies.
Consensus is the hardest trophy will be defeating Priest without getting hit.
The rest seems pretty straightforward.
Why, oh why isn't that pinnacle of Ubisoft game design released physically at retailers? Why does it have to be lrg only? I hate that with my heart.
Very excited to replay this game, it’s been many years, I suppose around 21!
@rusty82 while that's true, you did read the review about how it's regarded nowadays? And my point still stands about remasters in general.
@DarianStarfrog are we reading the same comment?
@BecauseBecause I agree with the most points you make. But you imply remasters are done for games that are proven sellers as it's less risk but in case of this it's not true
@kendomustdie @LazyLombax Thanks both.
S
Might pick this up at somepoint. Never played it when it released so lets see what all the fuss is about 🤣
Never played the original and the price is very reasonable. I have plenty to play atm though, so onto the wish list this goes!
I played it on PS3 when they remastered it the first time and thought it was fine. It had elements of Jak & Daxter and Sly Cooper but I didn't feel it was as good as either. I never understood what the hype was about and certainly don't understand the clamor for a sequel that's been in development hell for as long as it's been. Might pick it up on sale if that sequel ever gets a release window.
Tangentially related anecdote:
Near the end of the PS2 lifespan, I traded in my second revision "fat" PS2 for one of the later revision slim models. Apparently there were hardware changes in later revisions of slim PS2s that introduced compatibility problems in a small number of PS2 games.
Beyond Good and Evil was one of those games. A few years back I wanted to try replaying the original version of BG&E only to find that it basically unplayable on the slim PS2 due to numerous issues.
I was pretty pissed about that. I knew the PS2 slim was less compatible with PS1 games, but had no clue that it even had some compatibility issues with PS2 games. I wish I had kept my original model PS2.
Anyway, I'll picking this up for sure.
@TrevorO Yes, you can! I was watching a video review last night and the person specifically showed and called out this new option.
Still a bit of a concern on if the camera is a bit wonky as I got too far into one of the maze like sections with guards last lime on PS3 & lost & stuck it'd need a restart....there's an intriguing story underneath. Oh well,will keep an eye out for a discount later.
Still bums me out the ideas for a single player focused sequel back in the ps3 era got abandoned by Ubisoft/Ancel in favour of the MMO online live service pipedream monstrosity with swearing gorillas...what a waste of an IP!😑
20 quid is a reasonable price but can't really justify buying it if it's going straight onto the backlog. Unfortunately for remasters like these, there's just too many other good games to play and too little time in the day.
@kendomustdie Does the game run at 60fps on PS4? I can't find this confirmation anywhere, and for me it will be the deciding factor on whether I buy on Switch or PS4.
@sketchturner I installed the PS4 version on my Pro and played the opening up to the first Mamago Garage visit. It seemed to be as stable as the PS5 version. Hope that helps
@kendomustdie Unfortunately, I've got an OG PS4, so I'm not sure that performance on a Pro would necessarily help me. Thanks anyway!
@Bentleyma I can remember playing Avatar, and having it crash a few times. And whilst flying, some of the visuals of the sky were all messed up.
But there was a quick patch update, and whatever issues I had with it seemed to be fixed.
But then again, Hogwarts Legacy had the same problem with the skies. Or was I the only one who had that problem?
@sketchturner from what I've heard it's 60fps on consoles all except switch which is 30fps
Love to see it. But damn, there’s so much out here to play already.
I know it’s an old game but clunky combat is a hard no from me.
Tap here to load 64 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...